Phone Case

For two years I have had this case:
https://www.walmart.com/ip/BODY-GLOVE-9420703-SAMSUNG-R-GALAXY-S-R-5-SHOCKSUIT-CASE-BLACK-CHARCOAL/39753449#about-item

It's the Body Glove Shocksuit case I purchased from the T-Mobile store. However, it's now cracking and breaking...after two years!!!

I wouldn't be so annoyed but my last phone case lasted the length of the phone: five years so I naturally expect the same.

Now, it appears my 2014 phone is archaic and off the internet, my choices are limited. I thought about buying two so I wouldn't have to do this again but my mom reminded me how quickly plastic and rubber degrades nowadays.

So...

Lifeproof or Otterbox?